Fair to Compare “FairTax” vs. “Fair Tax”?

The Sunday Editorial in The Herald…
The issue: “FairTax” vs. “Fair Tax for Lee County”
Our view: Don’t be fooled. They’re BOTH doing good work.

With Election Day coming Tuesday, and with campaigns gearing up for the final push, we’re reminded that politics is a sophisticated business. Everywhere, strategists and consultants and professional marketing firms are working overtime to figure out how to sway voters. Issues are important, but in our busy electronic age, who has time for them? Sound bites and imaging work just as well.

So does deception.

Most successful strategies require plenty of thought, but sometimes the brainstorm is more sudden; occasionally, a campaign strategy appears as if it were manna sent from heaven. That’s how organizations opposed to the .25-cent sales tax measure on Tuesday’s ballot must have felt when it occurred to them that the national “FairTax” movement and the local “Fair Tax for Lee County”
push and were similar enough stir already-muddy waters.

“FairTax” (two words pushed together as one) is, according to www.fairtax.org, a comprehensive proposal that would replace all federal income and payroll-based taxes with an integrated, revenue-neutral approach that includes a progressive national retail sales tax and a repeal of the 16th amendment. Their stance is: “Let’s abolish the IRS and make April 15 just another spring day.”

“Fair Tax (two words) for Lee County” is the name of a local ad hoc group operating and based out of the Sanford Area Chamber of Commerce which, with the blessing and endorsement of a long list of business, education and civic-minded individuals and organizations, favors the .25-cent increase in the local sales tax (back to the level it was last summer) to help fund repairs and renovations at Lee County High School and at Central Carolina Community College. Their stance is: “Because everyone pays it (including those shopping here from other counties), and because it has far less impact than a property tax increase, let’ s approve the .25-cent sales tax.”

Confused? Probably not. But the anti-tax groups are telling you that you should be, insisting that the Chamber, in taking on the assignment of putting together the local group, has intentionally hijacked the “FairTax” name – perhaps infringing upon a trademark along the way – to dupe voters. Dallas Woodhouse, the state director of Americans for Prosperity, told The Herald this week that it’s “a shame” that supporters of the .25-cent tax are “so desperate to raise taxes they will try to fool the public.”

If the shoe fits…

In reality, AFP has, by all appearances, resorted to desperation to defeat the tax. They used minor scare tactics this week in a “mayday” event to issue a “distress call” about the tax. Then, seeing an opportunity to take advantage of the similarity between “Fair Tax for Lee County” and “FairTax,” they pounced.

In this space one week ago, The Herald endorsed the .25-cent sales tax. We said then that regardless of whatever poor planning and execution had put Lee County High School in its state of disrepair, the sales tax issue on Tuesday’s ballot was the best way to immediately take steps to fix the problems. There’ll be plenty of time to address legitimate concerns raised by anti-tax groups such as AFP and the John Locke Foundation as we move forward, but we need to act today.

We need to approve the .25-cent sales tax because it is, ultimately, a fair tax.


One Response to Fair to Compare “FairTax” vs. “Fair Tax”?

  1. Joe McDonald says:

    Lee County was not alone in defeating the .25 Sales Tax. All but Cumberland County fell victim to the John Lock Society, ie AFP propaganda featured in newspapers across the state. The Sanford Herald could have featured the AFP article on the inside page , but chose to inflict our citizens with this propaganda on the the front, above the fold space. Once again, the Herald who apparently supported the sales tax did little to actually educate the public to the importance of its passage . A front page, above the fold article espousing the merits of a sales tax versus a property tax increase would have gone a long way in educating voters . It is not too late. The sales tax can go on the ballot in November and I challenge the Herald to take the lead in promoting its passage. Start now educating the community on the value of having safe, clean, environmently confortable space to education our young people.
    Our goal should be to pass the sales tax in November with the understanding our County Commissioners will allocate the dollars from the tax to K-14 school renovations. It is up to the County Commissioners to decide if the renovations should take one, three or five years depending on the budgetary needs of the County. My hope is the Herald will play a pivotal role in encouraging our citizens to do the right thing for our community and our school systems and support the sales tax in November.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: